Reviewers FAQs

Q: How can I obtain credit for the reviews that I have submitted? A: Reviewers are offered a certificate detailing their peer review contributions with us. Additionally, reviews can be added to online profiles such as ORCID or Publons for further recognition.

How to Submit Your Review

Q: How do I submit my review? A: All reviews are processed through the OJS system. To participate, you must register on the journal's website as a reviewer.

Staying Updated on Journal News

Q: Are there ways to keep informed about any updates of the journal? A: Yes, you can subscribe to our monthly email newsletter, which includes announcements and news sent directly to your inbox.

How Editors Select Reviewers

Q: How do editors select reviewers? A: Reviewers are chosen based on several factors, with expertise being the most critical. We aim to receive expert feedback on all aspects of the submitted article. To ensure a diverse and global perspective, we regularly seek new reviewers to join our panel, while also relying on experienced reviewers to maintain consistency across reviews.

How to Become a Peer Reviewer

Q: How can I become a peer reviewer? A: We are continually looking for new peer reviewers to diversify our global pool. To increase your visibility to editors, ensure your work is easily accessible online. An up-to-date laboratory webpage and an active ORCID profile are essential. Additionally, express your interest by emailing the editors and registering on the journal's website as a reviewer.

Reviewing Manuscripts with Potential Conflicts of Interest

Q: Should I agree to review a manuscript if I have co-authored an article with an author of this manuscript? A: Generally, we avoid asking past collaborators to review each other's manuscripts. However, if a significant amount of time has passed (e.g., 3-5 years) or the co-authorship does not reflect a close association, an exception may be made. Discuss any potential conflicts with the editor for guidance.

Q: Should I agree to review a manuscript if I am working on a similar article? A: If you are writing a similar article, discuss with the editor whether you can provide an unbiased review.

Q: Should I agree to review a manuscript if I used to be a member of the author’s research group? A: Whether you should review depends on your current relationship with the group and your level of independence in your career. Close associates are generally avoided as reviewers. Discuss your situation with the editor before accepting the invitation.

Q: Should I still review a manuscript if I’ve already reviewed it for another journal? A: Reviewing the same manuscript for another journal is not an issue, as long as you can objectively assess it according to our journal's standards.